Written by the Speak Up! team
Your yearly performance review is coming up, and you start wondering, “What would it take this time to deny me the promotion I’m expecting?”
You remember the words used to describe you in your last performance review. Quiet. Intense. Too emotional. Too direct. Needs more presence. The comment arrived with a smile, “You are doing a great job but… “, and a development plan. You walked out of the meeting unsure whether the problem was your work or your personality.
Often it is neither. It is a gap between the traits you bring and the picture of a leader the reviewer carries in their head. This article explains the character and personality traits pillar, why some traits get called “leadership” while others get called “development areas,” and how that gap feeds the self-doubt many people call imposter syndrome.
What are character and personality traits in leadership?
Your personality traits are your usual patterns: how you take in a room, make decisions, handle pressure, and connect with people. Your character traits are the qualities you act on when something is at stake, such as honesty, loyalty, patience or courage. Together, they form one of the pillars of my inside-out approach: your leadership story starts with who you already are, as explained in how your background becomes your leadership story.
At work, these traits show up in small moments. You speak first or last in a meeting. You deliver bad news in a hallway or in writing. You defend your team out loud or behind closed doors. Each choice tells people who you are before your title does.
Knowing which traits are yours is part of self-awareness as a leadership skill. This pillar asks a sharper question: which of those traits have you learned to hide?
Why do some traits count as “leadership” and others don’t?
Decades of research show a clear pattern in who gets seen as a leader. A 2002 meta-analysis in the Journal of Applied Psychology pooled 222 correlations from 73 samples and found extraversion was the most consistent trait linked to leadership, both to who emerged as a leader and to who was rated effective.
That finding describes the leader most workplaces expect: talkative, assertive, quick to take the floor. It does not tell you whether a reflective listener could lead just as well. A newer study shows what happens to people whose natural style runs the other way.
In a 2020 paper in PNAS, researchers Jackson Lu, Richard Nisbett and Michael Morris ran nine studies with more than 11,000 participants in the United States. East Asians were less likely than South Asians and white Americans to reach leadership positions, a pattern often called the “bamboo ceiling.” South Asians were more likely than white Americans to lead. The gap was explained by cultural differences in assertiveness, not by prejudice or lack of motivation. In the authors’ words, “The bamboo ceiling is not an Asian issue, but an issue of cultural fit.”
The researchers connect that lower assertiveness to East Asian communication norms in which speaking up forcefully can feel like a threat to group harmony. Seen from inside those norms, the same behavior is a strength: thinking before speaking, listening fully, protecting the cohesion of the team. The authors’ recommendation is aimed at organizations, not individuals: understand these differences and widen the picture of what a leader looks like.
Which traits do people hide at work?
Most people don’t consciously decide to hide a trait. They adjust after one comment, then another, until the adjustment feels like who they should be. A few common versions:
- The reflective thinker. You wait until you have something worth saying. Your review says, “We need to hear more from you.”
- The direct speaker. You name the problem plainly because you respect people’s time. You are told to “soften the delivery.”
- The warm connector. You notice who is struggling and check in. Someone calls it being “too emotional” for a tough decision.
- The respectful team player. You defer to seniority and credit the group. Your manager reads it as “not owning your work.”
Each of these traits can be a leadership strength in the right room. Hiding them has a price, which we covered in the mental tax of holding back. It also changes how you see yourself, and that is where imposter feelings tend to grow.
Were you passed over for a promotion or didn’t get the funding you needed for your business? Sometimes, you think it’s personal, and you try to deal with it the best way you can.
Other times, discrimination comes from peers and people you trust, mainly if you have acquired a specific leadership position or recognition. You must be aware of these circumstances while building your leadership skills and path to your goals. I was once accused of being “hostile” when I didn’t get what I wanted the moment I wanted it by a Latino “friend.”
I had pursued sponsorships from a county agency for my organization, and despite promises made, it was denied. I was upset and expressed my disappointment very clearly to the officer in charge, who was also Latinx.
Buddies talk, so a few days later I received this call from the first Latino man, my “friend.” He called me to congratulate me on my birthday that day, and then he shook that “recommendation” at me.
“I’m told you get hostile when you don’t get what you want when you want it.” He recommended to be patient to get the support I was looking for. I guess as a woman, I had to wait for “the powers that be” to dignify the request for my growing women’s organization, while men-led organizations were receiving the support they requested.
The support never came; on the contrary, I was ostracized and sidelined.
Not without grieving the loss of a friendship, I found this incident a motivation to expand my initiative nationwide. We ended up having members and supporters in 45 states and several Latin American countries.
Imposter syndrome: when the doubt comes from the template
Imposter syndrome is the persistent feeling that your success is undeserved and that someone will soon find you out. Psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes first described it in a 1978 study of high-achieving women, calling it the “impostor phenomenon.”
It is far from rare. A systematic review in the Journal of General Internal Medicine covered 62 studies with 14,161 participants. Reported rates ranged from 9% to 82%, depending on how it was measured, and were especially high among ethnic minority groups. It appeared in men and women and at every career stage. The same review notes it is not an officially recognized clinical diagnosis.
Writers Ruchika Tulshyan and Jodi-Ann Burey pushed the conversation further in Harvard Business Review with “Stop Telling Women They Have Imposter Syndrome.” Their article opens with Talisa Lavarry, who led a major project at work and came away exhausted, wondering whether her race shaped how she was treated. Their argument: the label turns a workplace problem —bias and exclusion— into a personal flaw the employee is expected to fix.
That is the link to this pillar. When your natural traits don’t match the leader your workplace pictures, the feedback keeps telling you that something about you is slightly off. After enough of it, doubting yourself starts to look like a reasonable conclusion. For a fuller look at the topic, read imposter syndrome at work.
Back to that word in your review
Read it again: quiet, intense, too emotional, needs more presence. It describes how one of your traits looked from one seat in one room, measured against one picture of a leader. It is information about the fit between you and that picture. It is not a verdict on whether you can lead.
The reflective thinker who was told to talk more may be the leader a team of strong voices needs. The direct speaker may be the one who gets a stalled project moving. Once you see the template, the word in your review stops being a description of your character and becomes what it always was: one person’s expectation. Leading from your own traits is the core of Speak Up!.
If a single review comment has turned into a voice that questions who you are, the free Name the Voice worksheet takes you through four steps to hear your inner critic, name it, check its claims and answer back.
FAQ
What are character traits in leadership?
Character traits in leadership are the qualities a leader acts on when something is at stake, such as honesty, fairness, courage and patience. They show up in decisions more than in words: who gets credit, how bad news is delivered, what happens when a mistake surfaces. People tend to trust a leader whose actions match these traits over time.
What is the difference between character and personality?
Personality describes your usual patterns of thinking, feeling and behaving, such as how outgoing or reserved you are. Character describes the values-driven choices you make, such as being honest when it costs you. Personality shapes how you lead; character shapes what you stand for while you do it.
Which personality traits are linked to leadership?
Extraversion has the most consistent link to leadership in the research. A 2002 meta-analysis of 73 samples found it predicted both who emerged as a leader and who was rated effective, with conscientiousness and openness to experience also playing a role. These findings describe who tends to be chosen and rated as a leader, which reflects workplace expectations as well as ability.
What is the bamboo ceiling?
The bamboo ceiling describes the underrepresentation of Asians, especially East Asians, in U.S. leadership positions. A 2020 study in PNAS found the gap was explained by cultural differences in assertiveness rather than by prejudice or motivation. The authors recommend that organizations widen their picture of what a leader looks like.
Is imposter syndrome a real diagnosis?
Imposter syndrome is not an officially recognized clinical diagnosis. A systematic review of 62 studies found it is common among both men and women and is often linked with depression, anxiety and burnout. If self-doubt is affecting your health or work, a licensed mental health professional can help.
Edited with AI.



