By the Speak Up! Team
“What goes around comes around” or “you reap what you sow” are some of the most common phrases we hear when we talk about karma. The Merriam-Webster Dictionary offers this explanation: “The force generated by a person’s actions held in Hinduism and Buddhism to perpetuate transmigration and in its ethical consequences to determine the nature of the person’s next existence.” That is, in these religions’ view, each individual is born with a residual from past lives that must be resolved. And until you do, you keep repeating the same patterns.
That lesson comes in different ways. For instance, your mind can cast a new colleague in an old role before you notice it happening. In years of experiments, psychologist Susan Andersen and her colleagues at New York University found that when a new person resembles someone important from your past, even in small ways, your mind automatically applies what it knows about that old relationship to the newcomer. The feelings come along too, and so does the version of you that lived in that relationship. They call this the relational self.
That may explain a familiar workplace puzzle. You change jobs thinking you are leaving a toxic environment, and within a few months the new boss or a colleague feel exactly like the old one. You end up in the same tense meetings, trying to win the same approval, swallowing the same objections. Different company, same story.
What it is: karmic relationships as a lens
A “karmic relationship” feels fated and intense and keeps teaching the same hard lesson until you learn it. It is not a scientific concept, and this article doesn’t treat it as one. It works better as a lens: a way to notice that certain relationships in your working life keep repeating their shape, even when the people change.
At work, the patterns are usually easy to recognize once you name them:
- The approval loop. Every manager becomes someone you must win over, and you never quite feel you have.
- The rescue loop. You keep picking up the colleague who drops the ball and resenting it.
- The rivalry loop. One peer in every team becomes your measuring stick.
- The peacekeeper loop. You absorb every conflict so the room stays calm.
Psychology has a tested idea that sits close to this lens. In Andersen’s research, the same cues that trigger an old relationship also bring back the self you were in it: your mood, your expectations, how you see yourself (Andersen and colleagues, Frontiers in Psychology, 2016). The pattern repeats because you walk in already playing your part.
How it connects: the role you play, and the traits it hides
Speak Up! Tell Your Story to Influence Others builds leadership on four pillars: values, character and personality traits, cultural attributes, and leadership interaction skills. Recurring relationship patterns sit squarely in the second one.
Each loop comes with a role. The pleaser, the rescuer, the rival, the peacekeeper. A role is useful at first, because it got you through a hard relationship. Over time, it stands in for your real traits. The pleaser stops showing her judgment. The peacekeeper stops showing his directness. Your colleagues meet the role, and the role is what gets reviewed, promoted, or passed over. (For more on how traits get hidden, see Character and Personality Traits: Are You Hiding Them?)
Culture can make a role feel even more natural. Many Latin American professionals grow up with simpatía, a cultural script that researchers describe as being warm, courteous, and easygoing, and working to keep relationships smooth (Triandis et al., Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1984). Individuals vary in how much they hold this value. Where it is strong, it is a real leadership asset: people trust you, teams stay together, hard news lands more gently.
Similar to Latin American simpatía, several global cultures prioritize interpersonal warmth, empathy, and social harmony through distinct cultural ideals. In Greece, philotimo represents a selfless “love of honor” rooted in hospitality and gracious duty toward others, while Japanese culture emphasizes amae (mutual emotional closeness) and omoiyari(empathetic anticipation of others’ feelings) to preserve smooth, non-confrontational relationships. Across sub-Saharan Africa, the philosophy of ubuntu (“I am because we are”) champions communal harmony, kindness, and mutual care, whereas Southern European traditions like Italian buona educazione and French politesse rely on grace and courteous social scripts to minimize daily friction and preserve mutual dignity.
The strain comes when that strength hardens into the peacekeeper role. You smooth over a conflict that needed to surface. You agree in the meeting and disagree in the hallway. This is the double pressure of role stress: honoring the warmth you were raised with while meeting a workplace that rewards open disagreement. Both sides can leave you feeling like you are performing someone.
The cost of faking it
Playing a role all day has a name in workplace research: surface acting, which means showing feelings you don’t actually have, or hiding the ones you do. A meta-analysis of 95 studies by Ute Hülsheger and Anna Schewe found surface acting had strong links to poorer well-being, including emotional exhaustion and psychological strain, and to lower job satisfaction. Deep acting, where people genuinely shift how they feel about a situation, showed only weak links to those problems.
The difference matters for recurring patterns. A role you keep replaying is surface acting stretched over months or years. The Association for Psychological Science, summarizing this research, notes that surface acting is associated with burnout and physical symptoms of stress.
The effects described here are patterns across many people, not a diagnosis. They can look like tiredness that a weekend doesn’t fix, dread before one particular meeting, or a sense that the person your colleagues know is not quite you. We explored a similar split in Severance and self-censorship.
If playing a role at work has started to wear on your health, please consider talking with a licensed mental health professional or your Employee Assistance Program.
Roles often come with an inner voice that keeps them in place. The free Name the Voice worksheet takes you through four steps to hear your inner critic, name it, check its claims, and answer back.
The relationship that keeps coming back
A karmic relationship, seen through this lens, is less about fate and more about memory. The same kind of person walks in, an old self answers, and the story runs again. Workplaces increasingly reward people who lead as themselves instead of a polished version, which makes a role you outgrew years ago more costly to keep.
Think of the person at work who most reminds you of someone from your past. Which version of you shows up when they walk into the room?
FAQ
What is a karmic relationship?
A karmic relationship is a term from spiritual and self-help writing for a relationship that feels fated, intense and repetitive. People use it to describe connections that keep teaching the same difficult lesson. It is a metaphor, not a psychological diagnosis or a scientific category.
Why do I keep having the same problem with every boss?
One reason is that your mind applies old relationships to new people. Research on transference and the relational self shows that when a new person resembles someone important from your past, you tend to bring the old expectations and the old version of yourself into the new relationship. Noticing the resemblance is often the first step to responding differently.
What is surface acting at work?
Surface acting means displaying emotions you don’t feel, or hiding the ones you do, to meet what the job expects. A meta-analysis of 95 studies linked it with poorer well-being and lower job satisfaction. Deep acting, where you genuinely change how you see the situation, showed much weaker links to those problems.
Can pretending to be someone else at work affect your mental health?
Yes, sustained pretending is associated with exhaustion and stress. Research on surface acting, summarized by the Association for Psychological Science, connects it with burnout and physical stress symptoms. If it is affecting you, a licensed mental health professional or an Employee Assistance Program can help.
What does simpatía mean?
Simpatía is a cultural script, common in many Latin American communities, that values warmth, courtesy, and smooth relationships. Researchers described it in a 1984 study of Hispanic and non-Hispanic participants in the United States. Individuals differ in how strongly they hold it.
Edited with AI.



